Interesting design question... we always want what we don't have!
My Hondas all have yellow tint in the turn signal area, so never thought twice about it. On the Insight, that the rear turn signal didn't have yellow tint stood out to me and I still consider adding yellow tint film to the cover. At certain rear angles and lighting, a slight yellow glow is visible when not active but for the most part, the rear turn signal looks clear.
From a 'symmetry' standpoint, I like the Japanese design since both the front and rear turn signals would match (clear). But from a 'tradition' standpoint, I'd stick with the U.S. design.
Added some pictures below for side-by-side comparison of the subtlety.